Just listening to the original samples...Blueprint 1 is..

RigorMortis

Army Of Darkness
ill o.g.
Streetwize said:
y'all act as if jay wasnt a struggling artist
No I wasnt, i just dont like his music boy.

jay was grindin and hustlin, gettin rejected by every fuckin label there is in the industry and him and damon dash created their own label
Yeah Jay is a good biznizman but I really dont care about that. So was the guy who invented toiletpaper, but everybody wipes his ass with his product.

wings, you're a hater fa real. i respect u and your music but your music views on jayz are wrong. same with nas
I think Wings is just stating his opinion, and you are hating on that coz it is in conflict with your opinion. I on the otherhand am straight dissin.

so if aesop rock EVER breaks it into commercial, would u stop likin him cos hes givin a 'bad name' by going commercial?
I dont think he would but if he would more power to him, he deserves it, cause his talent and skillz go far beyond most.

aesop is only lyrics, his voice is wack, his delivery sucks, his flow is average. and thats not me hatin on underground kats, i love underground hiphop, shit im an UG hiphop producer tryna get into the industry and i worked with underground kats.
His voice is cewl, you might not like it and his delivery rocks, take a better listen. His flow is above mcing he is a fucking superrhymer.

y'all are just hatin on jay.
That sounds so schoolyard and so gay, you dont like the music i like you must be hating i am going to tell my mom..

u think its that easy to sell 40 million records + over 8 years? hell no
That is the bizniz part again, we talkin about music here boy.

if u cant respect jayz as a hiphop artist, then ur more the fool
I aint disrespecting, to me his is just overrated.
 
ill o.g.
StressWon said:
I think "Low End Theory" is one of the Best Production Albums!

Hell Yea.

The live drums they have on that are so fuckin raw, if id had that drumkit i would be jammin all day instead of programmin my drums.

Plus the live bassists on there were hot too. But the drums were the best part.

Plus Qtip. He was real well spoken imo on that album.
 

Streetwize

Beat Architects !
ill o.g.
Battle Points: 49
RigorMortis said:
No I wasnt, i just dont like his music boy.


Yeah Jay is a good biznizman but I really dont care about that. So was the guy who invented toiletpaper, but everybody wipes his ass with his product.


I think Wings is just stating his opinion, and you are hating on that coz it is in conflict with your opinion. I on the otherhand am straight dissin.


I dont think he would but if he would more power to him, he deserves it, cause his talent and skillz go far beyond most.


His voice is cewl, you might not like it and his delivery rocks, take a better listen. His flow is above mcing he is a fucking superrhymer.


That sounds so schoolyard and so gay, you dont like the music i like you must be hating i am going to tell my mom..


That is the bizniz part again, we talkin about music here boy.


I aint disrespecting, to me his is just overrated.

dude ur acting as if im a commercial fan and i only love ppl who break into the industry. jayz is one of my favourite rappers and im more underground fan than i am commercial.like i'll say again, ur an idiot if ur a hiphop fan and dont realise what jayz has done in hiphop. ur just hatin, thats it.

shit i love the underground, i dont like aesop all that much but i definetely respect it, one of the illest lyricists ever in hiphop. shall i say that he is bad for hiphop cos i dont like him? no. he deserves his props but at the end of the day, he will never touch jays accomplishments in hiphop. i love vast aire, cannibal ox, common, talib, atmosphere, all these dudes. im even gona be working soon with immortal technique. so i bet I DO like some of the music u do

u guys think im on jays dick but im not, im stating the truth when i say HE HAS NOT GIVEN HIPHOP A BAD NAME

if u believe that, ur a str8 fool
 

DJ Hoppa

Broken Complex Records
ill o.g.
Battle Points: 50
Jay-Z doesnt give Hip hop a bad name.

Haters give hip-hop a bad name.

ive said it before, ill say it again.
Please dont hate.

I saw Jay-Z @ the Roxy (won tickets on the beat) in an intimate setting, about 100 people.
I dont believe in what he raps about.
But he is FUCKING ILL. Amazing delivery, breath control, crowd interraction.

He deserves EVERYTHING HES GOT.

Fuck MTV, but Jay-Z is DOPE.

And im the last motherfucker to be talking about guns, hoes, murder, and money. But so what?
Thats what he lived, lives, and will live, thats what he rhymes about. But it is still HIP HOP.

my 2 cents
 

DJ Hoppa

Broken Complex Records
ill o.g.
Battle Points: 50
no matter where your at in life, and how much energy you put into what you do, there will be someone else putting that SAME AMOUNT OF ENERGY into HATING YOU.

Fuck that.
 

tricky spinz

Dead Man Walkin
ill o.g.
Battle Points: 12
man, how many fuckin times do we have to go over this. it all comes down to that good music is good music, but one persons idea of good music is not another persons and we all need to just fuckin accept that what one dude likes, another may think is whack as shit. so just everybody show a little respect to each other. if one guy wants to say its whack then let him. if one guy wants to say its the bomb then let him. but theres no need to throw any personal attacks out there.
 

RigorMortis

Army Of Darkness
ill o.g.
Streetwize said:
dude ur acting as if im a commercial fan and i only love ppl who break into the industry. jayz is one of my favourite rappers and im more underground fan than i am commercial.like i'll say again, ur an idiot if ur a hiphop fan and dont realise what jayz has done in hiphop. ur just hatin, thats it.

shit i love the underground, i dont like aesop all that much but i definetely respect it, one of the illest lyricists ever in hiphop. shall i say that he is bad for hiphop cos i dont like him? no. he deserves his props but at the end of the day, he will never touch jays accomplishments in hiphop. i love vast aire, cannibal ox, common, talib, atmosphere, all these dudes. im even gona be working soon with immortal technique. so i bet I DO like some of the music u do

u guys think im on jays dick but im not, im stating the truth when i say HE HAS NOT GIVEN HIPHOP A BAD NAME

if u believe that, ur a str8 fool

I am not acting as if you are a commercial fan, i was just stating some of my opinions about the things you said. Nowhere i said you are a commercial fan and you only love peeps who break through.
I understand what he has done and i am not hating what is up with the whole hating thing. I declare everyone gay who is using that word to lightly.
I just dont like his music that is all.
That is nice you working with immortal, let us know what you do. I know someone too who might do some production work for him. If he does I will let you know.

I dont know if he has given hiphop a bad name, he might but he also might not. There is much more worse shit out there that reeks like shit.
 

RigorMortis

Army Of Darkness
ill o.g.
...''just like neo in the matrix, fighting haters with all the same faces'' hehe
 

MadScientist

Geniuz
ill o.g.
Battle Points: 20
Why do people force there views and opinions on someone who disagrees? If I think the Blueprint sucks then it does (in my opinion) Maybe not to you but to say that someone is a hater, stupid, etc, etc, etc, because of there opinions is down right crazy. All your doing is hating on them for their views. What makes you or your opinion correct. These aren't facts they are personal feelings that everyone is entitled to. We should leave it at that.
 

9zeros

ILLIEN
ill o.g.
Battle Points: 1
holy shit there were a few posts in the morning but damn 4 pages when i came back

timbaland is great im a big fan but somebody mentioned big pimpin being genius and if you didnt
hear the original song that wouldnt be incorrect but i heard the sample i think i still have it if someone wants to hear it, haha he didnt change one thing he made some whoosh noises in the background for that one

and LIL JON IS THE GREATEST PRODUCER EVER ...................jk
 

Streetwize

Beat Architects !
ill o.g.
Battle Points: 49
MadScientist said:
Why do people force there views and opinions on someone who disagrees? If I think the Blueprint sucks then it does (in my opinion) Maybe not to you but to say that someone is a hater, stupid, etc, etc, etc, because of there opinions is down right crazy. All your doing is hating on them for their views. What makes you or your opinion correct. These aren't facts they are personal feelings that everyone is entitled to. We should leave it at that.

look dawg, im not getting into petty bullshit about this ok

i wasnt talking about the actual album, if they dont like it, fine.

all im saying is if people are saying stuff like 'jayz ruins hiphop blah blah'

u go to any fuckin mc in this industry, and tell em that and they will slap u. hiphop artists and fans around the world respect jayz for what hes done to hiphop. hes one of the people who can keep it real for the street people and for people commercially. if u cant admit that, then thats hating

stop fuckin makin me the bad guy in this shit
 

Streetwize

Beat Architects !
ill o.g.
Battle Points: 49
yeah i feel guilty for posting a simple thread and for it to turn into a damn debate

anyway, im outtta here

ima enjoy jayz - bp1
 
C

Copenhagen

Guest
I personally think that the Blueprint is a good album, not great, but good. I also find Timbaland to be a talented producer.
Aesop Rock is cool, so is many other 'underground' rappers, but I've listened to hip-hop for 16 years now, and don't really feel that genre as much anymore.
I am not really feeling people who just like something because it is played in heavy rotation on MTV, but nor do I really feel people who just like underground because it is underground and different.

Regarding the debate, Wings we're pals so I know you'd want my honest opinion, and I must admit, I think you started it. You came into the thread and heavily critiqued those who started the thread's opinion, and when they said the same of the artists you mentioned, then you got irritated.

Anyway, this isn't really something to debate about. One man's garbage is another man's treasure. This is just what happens when people don't respect that, or write their difference in opinion in such a way that it provokes.
 

Cold Truth

IllMuzik Moderator
ill o.g.
Battle Points: 25
arggh hh

i really got to disagree with you wings.... at least, for myself. i listen to co flow. i listen to everything def jux, really, i loved rawkus, i have heard the anticons and soles and heiro's and a lot of different ish..... i even give the southern dudes a listen (i have to at least know what im abuot to hate on/dislike!) from time to time.... i dont really care for 99% of it....

but still, that production style on blueprint suits me... i think sometimes people get so friggin caught up in being "underground" and obscure to find "talent" but truthfully a lot of this underground material is great material by talented people, but thats not my overall preferance.... bottom line, people like what they like..... i have a pretty well rounded taste in music and i personally loved all but two tracks on the blueprint... i personally loved that deliverance beat... thats good ol' ben (formerly of the roots and now with incubus) on the guitar there..... what is talent and what is good is all a subjective viewpoint, to be honest.... because canibal ox doesnt appeal to me the way, say, nas does. that sound is cool and ilike it, but i would take the blueprint's instrumentals over theirs any day (not every jay z album, but that one in particluar.)

so, im just saying, that just because people like something taht is commercial music, that doesnt mean that they are somehow limitd in their knowledge/understanding/exposure to other music....

how can you sit there and call anything inferior? just because it doesnt suit your tastes? yo uhave to understand, that the heart of music for a lot of people is the ability to relate to it. i relate to a lot of ish i hear from common and mos def... i even relate to a lot that i have heard from b sigel! when jay z does.. i love music i can relate to...

i also love music that makes me think- el-p, for one. i bought both rjd2's albums,the first just off of a description of his "left field" beats. i heard canibal ox for the first time after reading one of yuor signatures quoting vast air.

remember, just because its abstract and non-conformist, that doesnt make it "better", just like selling more units doesnt make you "better"- it just means you appeal to someone different.

all in all wings, i think you got to take this one on the chin- you know i got mad respect for you, as a person and artist.... but you kind of initiated this one!
 

Formant024

Digital Smokerings
ill o.g.
LoL! I just been reading this for the first time and I have absolutly no usefull comments ..... isnt that great!






But really, I get the impression people are talking to themselves or their best selective reflection...something...

It's like you have to dig and respect 2pac ( FOR EXAMPLE!) for all the good things he has done 'n achieved, lets certainly not forget all the good music he has made...

Really, it helps to commence a perfectly christian like thread, but the truth is that I respect 2pac just as much as the next person 6 feet under simply because I dont know him and clearly state to dislike his music and/or lifestyle ( wether there's a reason for it or not ). If I was to pass his grave I wouldn't dance on it, now that's hating'. I'd keep still and move because I'm on a graveyard and I'm simply not interested, it's complete indifference. Some people dont understand, especialy because they consider him to be the king of hiphop, to me this implies that you're living in a completly different world. It's about the perspective of the individual, I can respect that, the individual that is, not the music nor it's industrial modus operandi or the credibility/skills.

These are harsh words that get taken personal and it troubles the opposite's course of fixation, mine remains unaffected. Their perspective to this side of the hiphop, where majors drain money like leeches, in fact, where majors dominate and monopolise every aspect belonging to commercial hiphop, has been completly created, and if not, formed n shaped by the rnd department. Now these "managers" can fetch any crappy product and force-market them into a lucrative exploit. This succeeds and the ultimate goal is achieved, the ghetto rapper gets to live the american dream, the major lives it up a bit more. Main thing is, our rapper is out the ghetto or can permitt a good life in it for as long as the fame lasts.

^^^^^None of this has to do with respect....

The thing is, to get back at the Jay-Z issue, if I'm at a club I could be dancing to Jay-Z ehm, no ... dancing to Beyonce's track ( the one with jay-z rapping lame ) sweatin' my balls to it all night long. It doesn't happen often because I prefer to go clubbin' to different music. But when I get into a conversation on the subject of hiphop, Jay-Z doesn't even exist in my book, nor do all the chart bombing hiphop exploits. Maybe it's a personal definition of what I assume is underground, while a lot of cats into Kanye, Jay-Z, the lot, consider them being underground. In most cases I'll ask for their definition of underground rap since they WERE underground once. In my book you're either underground or not, if your exploitation is biased for the charts you're no longer underground. Dont confuse indy with underground, that simply means people want to keep the money they earn and are patient enough not to do things the easiest and quickest way. They want to bring the music they like and exploit their idea's on their own scale and terms and its the hard way doing it all yourself. But at least you know what your talking about and you make yourselves as less depending on anything. See what happens when you give a struggling kid from the ghetto the wellfare he dreams off....he knows nada on nothing besides rapping or playing beatmachine, get in the process of succes and receives the bill afterwards to his shocking surprise. Cars, houses and the stuff is nice but have stay real and open up a serious can of asswhooping perspective to maintain this like a job. Your rep is fragile overthere, too much airplay makes you boring, before you know it you're out and it wasn't even your fault, its just that the PR on your case has exploited you to the max making you an almost obsolete product. I bare one thing in mind on whole entertainment industry and me in it, I want to do this till I'm 50 and working 2/3 years in it for the 5 minutes of fame just isnt worth it...


I certainly do not respect Jay-Z for the music he makes, for his lyrics, for his proclaimed " underground " title given here or where ever, for his company's achievement and especialy not because he gets to bang with Beyonce ....simply because all this has nothing to with respect and If I am up for good hiphop I know I wont find it while I'm at Club whatever. I would respect the man if I saw him helping an old man cross the street or feeding bread to a duck at the ghetto pond.

Lets do this last one over; the same statement trick, but without Beyonce.

I certainly do not respect Eminem for the music he makes, for his lyrics, for his proclaimed " underground " title given here or where ever, for his company's achievement or his movie. I would respect the man if he stopped rapping about his mother.

I certainly do not respect Kanye West for the music he makes, for his lyrics, for his proclaimed " underground " title given here or where ever, for his company's achievement and especialy not due to his attitude. I would respect the man he wasn't as racist as the ignorent white man talking 'bout them niggas.

I can go about this, but on a last note... Honestly, in general I have to say that i hear more things coming out of a underground biased person than a pimpy chart addict riding the new hypes. This is because most in their underground scenes, backpacker or not, will put more effort in finding about what or who they like from the realms of the underground. But I wont respect them for taking effort, it has nothing to with it. On the other side, you'll have to excuse me for stereotyping, but one as to claim underground to be bla,bla,bla...the pimpy chart addict, will know as much about the music he likes as the backpacker next to him because that music cant be avoided. It hard not to know when all these artist mentioned here in the thread are on the mtv, radio, internet, magazines, book, biographies, movies, ringtones, signatured sponsor gear, your gf's head or at the clubs spinning their records every weekend over and over for two months in a row till the next hype comes on.

To you people who know Im adressing to and I guess from an underground perspective, there's simply more to hiphop, I know and most you do not, even if they claim to have listen to some underground material which they obviously didn't like or wouldn't like in the first place.

To those peeps, grow up and learn to debate... then you gain the respect by itself, by your self.

Or you can go to soundclick.
 
ill o.g.
Battle Points: 3
Clarifications

YO,

this thread has gone out of hand. i certainly did not mean to cause such a heated debate.
but anyway - my explanations:

1. I DO NOT HATE\DISLIKE maintream\commercial music. I DO HATE\DISLIKE commercialism and its negative effects on music. music is music and it shouldn't turn into a business. especially, not into this whole shitty industry that has nothing to do with music.

2. i'm not a hater; all i want to say is: while it's true that music is all about emotions\feelings and so forth, sometimes people just have to explore and dig deeper. give me anything from jay z, and i'll show you a better tune (which discusses the same topic). show me a love song of his and i'll show you 100 better love songs; have you heard Immortal Technique's 'You Never Know' (amazing love story)? have you heard Cannibal Ox's 'The F-Word'? have you heard illogic's last LP? have you heard the INCREDIBLE 'Time Capsule' (Featuring Aesop Rock & Vast Aire)? and the list goes on and on. you gotta realize that i'm comparing comparable things. it's not like i said that Bill Evans is better than Thelonious Monk. in this case (and many other similar cases) the music is too different to be compared. two different worlds.
but it's TOTALLY AND COMPLETELY POSSIBLE to compare Bubba Sparxxx with Illogic. Illogic is a poet, while Bubba Sparxxx is god knows what. you know what? there are many artists that you just can't compare with others. there ain't no point comparing aesop rock with illogic or vast aire. they are all excellent and extremely talented poets. in these cases, one can only express his personal preference, but saying that A is better than B is just wrong. same goes for the beats. but again - i can and will always claim that no matter what, MOST (BUT NOT ALL) of the underground cats are ten times better than any mainstream artist. simply because most mainstream artists do their thing just for the money (and other unworthy reasons). they lack soul and spirituality. plus, i think that ya'll are wrong regarding the definition of underground. at least in my eyes: UNDERGROUND = AN ALTERNATIVE FOR THE COMMERCIAL MARKET = (IN MOST CASES) BETTER MUSIC, BETTER QUALITY (LYRICS+MUSIC WISE).
underground (to me) does not mean: artists who did not break into the commercial market. it's just an alternative - mostly people who are serious about their passion. people who put everything they got into music. people who understand music to the fullest extent.
don't go too far - listen to what vast aire has to say about the mainstream scene (def jux documentary). that's the truth fellows. i'm sorry, but it's just the way it is.
i may and may not produce for MTV, but as mercury waters said: i won't change myself and my music. if it will fit MTV - super, if it won't - i'm sorry.

3. thanks for respecting me as an artist and as a person. ya'll know that it's mutual; i respect ya'll as well - TO THE BONE. but in my opinion, some of you are not exactly right regarding this (rather important) issue.

4. as you all know, i usually stay NEUTRAL. however, i thought that this thread was the perfect place to state my opinion for a change. i respect every artist out there; i really do.
but i have even more respect to those who do their own thing; those who follow the rhythms of their heart; those who experiment; those who explore; those who take the time to listen and dig; those who put EVERYTHING (and beyond) into their thang; those who choose to give up on other things and concentrate on their own thang; those who do not follow the norm and have their own opinions; those who understand that music has other sides - not just MTV; those who choose QUALITY!
that's my mantra.

5. last point (i repeat): i do not hate on commercial\mainstream music. i am not a purist or a backpacker. i'm just a person who appreciates quality.

One Love,
Wings
 

Attachments

  • Underground.jpg
    Underground.jpg
    12 KB · Views: 109

trez260

ILLIEN
ill o.g.
IMO, Reasonable Doubt is Jay-Z best album. Beats, Rhymes. it was a perfect balance between street hustle/mainstream playa. every album after that got watered down as far as style, sound, and passion.
 
Top